From classroom to courtroom

How Mock Trial is supporting one student’s goal of becoming a criminal defense attorney.

A suited young man listens across a table as another person holds a wooden gavel.

Mock trial and real-world courtroom observations are preparing Nathaniel Rothstein for a career in law centered on compassion and advocacy.

A woman presents to a classroom audience while a man in a suit stands beside her.
The UMD Mock Trial team competes in the American Mock Trial Association and is coached by Kirstyn Oye J.D., an instructor of political science and assistant attorney for St. Louis County.

During eighth grade in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, Nathaniel Rothstein recalled being “bored out of my mind.” His older sister suggested he join their high school mock trial team. “I decided I'd give it a try,” he said. “I never thought it would blossom into a potential career path for me.”

Rothstein is studying criminology with plans to attend law school and become a criminal defense attorney. He chose the University of Minnesota Duluth to be closer to his grandmother in Duluth, for the campus size and proximity to Lake Superior, and for its affordability through the North Star Promise program. Building on his high school experience, he joined the UMD Mock Trial Team, led by Kirstyn Oye J.D., an instructor of political science and assistant attorney for St. Louis County.

“I reached out to her a few months before I arrived, and the first thing she told me was that the team is really focused on fun. That is exactly what I've experienced,” Rothstein said. “We're a tightly knit group.”

A suited man and a woman with a tablet smile while seated in a classroom.
From constitutional law to judicial politics, mock trial provides Nathaniel Rothstein with a practical setting to deepen what he's learning in the classroom.

The team competes in the American Mock Trial Association and will host a campus tournament in early December. To prepare, members meet regularly to rehearse. Dressed in business attire, they arrange classroom desks and chairs to replicate a courtroom. During a recent evening session, Rothstein sat near the front rehearsing as a witness, comfortably fielding questions from a teammate acting as the plaintiff's counsel.

“Mock Trial is really good for offering a foundational understanding of trial advocacy and legal reasoning,” Rothstein said. Rehearsing cases has reinforced his coursework while sharpening his skills in debate, public speaking and critical thinking.

Beyond Mock Trial, Rothstein is preparing for his legal career by observing court proceedings at the Ramsey County Courthouse and working as a legal assistant for a private criminal defense attorney in Minneapolis. These experiences confirmed his interest in criminal defense. “It's really important to recognize that people involved in the criminal justice system are people,” he said. “When you view them with compassion and understand their complexities, their actions and circumstances make much more sense.”

Back in the classroom, Rothstein and his teammates continue rehearsal as Oye demonstrates questioning techniques, testing Rothstein's preparation while sharing insight from her work as a practicing attorney.

“I’m enjoying the connections I've made up here,” Rothstein said. “Duluth is a great place.

Contact Us

College of Arts, Humanities, and Social Sciences

1208 Kirby Drive
Duluth, MN 55812
United States

You might also enjoy

Person wearing pink sunglasses and waders takes notes while standing among tall grasses.

Core experiences

How early curiosity about the natural world shaped one student’s path in environmental science.